Making Choices: Taking Pictures or Making Photographs

by | Aug 25, 2022

Some thought for today by Joe Farace

“Your first 10,000 photographs are your worst.”— Henri Cartier Bresson

There are all kinds of photographers out there in the world and I’m not just talking about portrait shooters, landscape photographers or astrophotographers. All of these genres also include (at least) four major categories of photographers that I’m about to describe. So lets get started:

Pixel Peepers: A photographer/friend of mine once showed me a portrait he made of a strikingly beautiful model and proudly told me, “look how sharp her eyelashes are.” I guess they were sharp but the expression on her face said, “when is this session ever going to end?” I’ll confess to shooting pictures of brick walls but, here’s the important part— only when writing a lens review. When it comes to lenses or even cameras that get used for my personal photography I just shoot’em and use’em. Ditto for DxO sensor scores; I never look at them for myself.

Let me tell you something else: The best hands-down, all-world best mirrorless camera that I ever tested was the Samsung NX1. When I looked at the images on my 5K iMac’s screen I was blown away by their stunning visual quality; it was better than anything that I’ve ever used, even today. But Samsung didn’t get the memo at the time about mirrorless camera size and the NX1 is as gone as quickly as the Nimslo. Since then, it seems like other manufacturers did get the memo either, witness the Panasonic S1 family of cameras. Perhaps Samsung was just ahead of their time.

How I made this photograph: It was shot near Aspen, Colorado with a Nikon 90s and Ektachrome film. It was scanned by Kodaks Photo CD process and was opened using Lemke Software’s GraphicConverter that produced fairly good quality files from a Photo CD disc but the software is not without its quirks for those people of using older computers and OS.

Camera Collectors: I’ll confess to having some of of genetic disposition as well starting with my Contax obsession.  Speaking of Contax, there is no doubt that some people admire the elegance and construction of the hardware, seldom take pictures but they do care if the camera is the latest or “the best.” I once wrote in Shutterbug back back when it was a real magazine, “if carpenters could hang a belt sander around their neck, they might not treat it as the tool it is” but that’s not they way it works out here in the real world. But lets face it, we’re all camera collectors to some extent.

I currently own a Leica M6 TTL, Zeiss SW, Seagull TLR, Leica Z2X and Minolta Prod 20, none of which I would part with after going digital, even though I seldom use any of these beautiful cameras—although after my experience with the Z2X that’s about to change. But it’s called, photography not cameratography and it’s all about making photos and not just collecting beautiful mechanical and optical Objet d’art. Although at the same time, I think that’s no excuse for making ugly-looking cameras.

Happy Snappers:  We are all snapshooters to some extent. I’m not talking about using cell phones to make selfies but shooting pictures, like I and everybody else does of birthdays, anniversaries and other special occasions. And for some people, like my friend Renee, it’s all they use their camera for and there’s nothing wrong with that. It’s one of a camera’s best uses and something that makes photography the universal language. Selfies, excepted, I think.

Photographers: I suspect there’s a bunch of people, much like me that just enjoy making photographs. Yes, we love cameras and lenses, although as tools not as objects of worship and make pictures of birthdays and anniversaries  too but also try to make images that are technically and aesthetically pleasing.

There are probably more different kinds of picture takers out there and if you can think of any—or you are one—please click that ole Contact button and tell me what you think. Or maybe you’re just a photographer yourself and want to talk about what you kind of images you like to make. Either way, I’d love to hear about that too. Best replies win a small prize.


If you enjoyed today’s blog post and would like to treat Joe to a cup of Earl Grey tea ($3.50,) click here. And if you do, many thanks.